“You don’t make pictures for Oscars.”
– Martin Scorsese
I’m going to say it, I was blown away by how little I was blown away this year. Once again, I was surprised to see how many of the presenters were better frocked than than the stars up for awards, quelle horreur! As we speak stylists and assistants are cringing and bracing themselves for the Louboutins to come sailing at them. Too many of the gowns were relatively colorless, and frankly more than a few people had major fit and styling issues – which means we have so much to talk about. Grab your junk food of choice and tell me what you thought of the frocks!
The Good


Jennifer Lawrence in Dior
Nicole Kidman in L’Wren Scott
Darkness and light! The Dior was early in a long list of white, pale, blush, nude, and pastel dresses, but I think this was by far the best. The fabric pattern give it some texture, and she looks as tall as an Amazon. I personally loved the backwards necklace, very Old Hollywood. Kidman brought some much needed va va voom to an otherwise fairly tame RC.


Amanda Seyfried in Alexander McQueen
Jessica Chastain in Armani
The pale frocks just keep rolling on. The McQeen was actually a lovely lavender and the only issue I have with her is that her makeup matched the gown too much. Chastain makes the cut because she frankly struggles on the RC (her baby blue boob monstrosity at the Golden Globes anyone?), and while I don’t love the color on her per se, I do love the color. Hair and jewels are flawless.


Charlize Theron in Dior
Naomi Watts in Armani
“I’m sorry, did those other ladies forget to bring the drama?” I imagine Theron said to Watts as they stepped from their limos. “That’s just fine, darling, because we’re here,” Watts said with a fabulous shoulder toss that nearly decapitated a wayward assistant. Let’s just all be grateful that finally Dior came through because we all remember the assault in dress form Theron sported a couple years ago, finally la Dior juste!


Fan Bing Bing in Marchesa
Jennifer Aniston in Maison Valentino
Oh thank heavens, this thing was filmed after the invention of technicolor! I have a couple of quibbles about the fit, but Fan Bing Bing is a glorious creature who wear things that mere mortals can’t – her chinoiserie inspired Cannes dress was magnificent, and she looks equally stunning her. The styling is really lovely. As for Aniston, I hated her hair but that deep red gown was really gorgeous.
The Meh


Amy Adams in Oscar de la Renta
Samantha Barks in Maison Valentino
Oh look…another pale gown…goody… I foresee this being a debate dress: I don’t hate it but I don’t think it’s anything special at all. Barks’ gown really is beautiful, and you can seldom go wrong with a good black gown…but it just seems a bit too (dare I say) dressed down? I want it in my closet, but I don’t think I want it on the Academy Awards RC.


Adele in Jenny Packham
Sandra Bullock
Adele has a specific aesthetic that she seldom deviates from, with good reason, but I don’t think this is one of its best incarnations. Sandra is wearing a vertical mullet, business on the top…what exactly is happening on the bottom?

Anne Hathaway in Prada
Anyone else surprised? I was surprised. She’s worn much better in her endless appearances running up to this shindig and her styling has been much better than this. The detailing of the back, which you can’t see here unfortunately, bag and jewels are lustworthy but let’s run through the list of grievances: first of all another blush tone, second the hair just is not looking its best, and worst of all that seaming. Anne Hathaway’s chest will be the Angelina Jolie’s leg of 2013, I fear. As I understand, it already has a twitter account.
The Bad


Reese Witherspoon in Louis Vuitton
Helen Hunt in H&M USA
I’ve got the blues, minions. I hate the side panels in the Vuitton, with a fiery passion. And Helen…H&M belongs in the mall not on the RC. Period. The jewels are lovely but she looks badly fitted and rumpled.


Octavia Spencer in Tadashi Shoji
Kristen Stewart in Reem Acra
And now I’ve got the nudes – which isn’t nearly as fun as it sounds. Octavia Spencer has a history and relationship with this house, but I think it they let her down a bit here. Her gown last year was gorgeous, but frankly I’m getting mother of the bride now. Doilies should never make it past the front door. And I have a sneaking suspicion that there is a waterfall of tulle down Stewart’s backside, which I decidedly disapprove of.

Jennifer Hudson in Roberto Cavalli
Hudson – NO. Whoever did you hair needs to drummed out of the guild immediately. I can see nothing else until that is fixed!
And the Ugly


Jane Fonda in MaisonValentino
Sally Field in Maison Valentino.
You two clearly have some commiserating to do do over how your stylists should be sacked. We’ll leave you to it. Valentino committed more than a few atrocities this year, in my opinion, and no amount of Samantha Barks can redeem these.

Melissa McCarthy in David Meister
Kill it with fire! I think gray is an undervalued color and actually makes her skin and hair color look great, but the fit is really not good, she needed something much more tailored to her figure. And, darling, your hair stylist has a grudge against you.
My Personal Favorite:

Stacy Kiebler in Naeem Khan
That is some fabulous art deco going on and I approve mightily.